Pause Giant AI Experiments: An Open Letter - Do you agree with the open letter calling for a PAUSE for six months?

I DISAGREE...

No way in hell anyone is going to "pause" their AI research. This genie isn't going back into its bottle.

Semi-transparentEarPod32

855

528

Pandora's Box is open and it's too late to even try to shut it which probably isn't even possible.

AngryRook13

574

538

I can't help noticing that Elon Musk has been sounding pretty annoyed about the OpenAI project he backed in the early days suddenly making a fortune since he stepped away from it - which according to reports happened after they rejected his 'offer' to take over leadership of the company - and has been talking of creating another of his own... I guess Elon needs a few months to try to catch up.

ThoughtfulEagle23

525

514

Presents a greater opportunity for nefarious actors to leap ahead.

Self-fortifyingRockstar79

522

1304

The problem with pausing the research is that it requires everyone with resources to agree to pause. That pause presents an opportunity for one of them to leap ahead.

InsidiousCapuccino47

517

652

Sorry, but no organization or company is going to slow down their AI development - especially if they have any amount of VC funding. Every day they don't work on it is cash up in flames. All a 6 month pause is going to do is allow those that are behind that don't adhere to the pause to catch up. The genie is out of the bottle and there is no going back.

WholesomeYam13

496

536

Stopping is not a feasible option considering China and Russia will simply continue and potentially overtake the rest of the world.

ElegantSprocket91

486

561

QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS

And everyone who sign the letter knows that "pause" just means stop releasing the latest version to the general public.

SprightlyCephalopod83

636

545

Link to the letter here

RevitalizedFox79

613

674

I'm guessing everyone who signed this, has heavy ties to and investments in China.

UnhingedAxe77

577

615

YouTube video on this debate link

DramaticRocket39

534

646

I think one of the most bizarre things about this discussion is the notion that humanity has a shared set of values. How are we ever going to solve alignment problems in AI when we can't solve them in ourselves?

EnigmaticHurdle91

526

509

Hence "arms race"

ArtificialCartographer01

521

632

Prisoner's Dilemma, Tragedy of the Commons.

DelightfulVortex68

514

614

So while "responsible" countries take a break, "irresponsible" countries continue research and gain an advantage? Brilliant!

WholesomeElephant38

512

They know full well that nobody is pausing anything. I think they're just doing this so if things go bad they can say they tried.

ImmenseYam85

504

540

So OpenAI says we can’t pause because others who don’t have our ethical governance won’t and then we won’t be able to counterbalance. But what is the point of ethical governance if you don’t follow it anyways?

CorrugatedElephant08

493

528

There is an AI battle between Google and Microsoft now. There will be no pause after this point.

GiganticArrow74

480

534

I AGREE...

As long as we can't reliably predict AI's and hadnt had the time yet to create actual failsafe systems to control the soon-to-be by faaar smartest Intelligence on our little planet we indeed should take a moment to figure out what we are actually doing. And not just to try being the very first to rush into to the abyss because of market competition.

Semi-impartialYam62

694

570

Maybe a regulatory body needs to be introduced to regulate Ai, it needs to be world wide though.

Happy LittleSapling29

685

1103

"Let's enjoy a long AI Summer, not rush unprepared into a Fall". Thanks for that.

PoliteBandicoot81

552

599

That's why Governmental intervention might be necessary in this case. But since it takes much longer than 6 Months, for them to decide on anything, my hopes are not very high in that regard...

CorrugatedHen67

464

690

Here is the thing. Get some Regulation in place. Asap. Remember how chaotic disinformation is already making things. Remember the movie gremlins. AI “gremlins” very damaging. must not be let loose. Put a framework in place. For levels of trust. And fast AI output and moderated by a human willing to have identify verified / known AI o

UnderratedSnake37

454

472

Reply

Hints and Tips

Keep your words and phrases to the point. Be as objective as you can.

Remember. Here, you are an intelligent entity of thoughts. You are not YOU. You are not bound by your personal beliefs, affiliations, etc. You can play devil's advocate, explore other ideas which you would never think of exploring as the real you.

Learn, understand other points of view. Become other points of view. Contribute to the tree of knowledge. You are but one leaf in a vast forest of intelligence. Make your thoughts known.

Know the type of question

Debatable questions
If the question is a debatable question, there is an immediate opportunity to agree or disagree. Formulate your responses and chose to either agree or disagree. If you have a question or a reply that is not picking a side for or against, use the Questions or Comments option.

Fielding questions
If the question asks for ideas on a particular topic, use the Questions or Comments option to reply with your ideas. This can lead to a debate on the pros and cons of your reply.